2

So, I am composing a piece representing winter and I am right in the middle of the piece(the piece is in Rondo form and I'm at the C section).

I started off in E major, then after being in the subdominant for a while, I went back to E major. That plagal motion is very smooth indeed. Then I switched from major to minor. Then, through a scalar motive of a minor third, I went from E minor to where I am at now, C major.

C major and E major are chromatic mediant chords. I have done smooth modulations in multiple ways, but one way in which I haven't done smooth modulations is by using an omnibus progression. An omnibus progression basically boils down to this:

Bass moves down a half step at a time

Upper voice moves up a half step at a time

Inner voices stay constant or if they need to move, the motion is minimal

Since I am writing the piece for a trio of piano, violin, and flute, it should probably be either the flute or the violin that takes the upper voice of the omnibus progression. That way the pianist doesn't run into the problem of unreachable notes(Which, as a pianist myself, I know that a ninth interval is the maximum interval size I can play and that while I can double the root and play all 4 notes in a diminished seventh, making 5 notes in an octave total, it is quite uncomfortable).

Now, I know that the second to last chord, I want to be either a B7 or a D#°7, since both of those are dominant function chords that will smoothly resolve to E major. Since I am in C major at the moment, I want to know if I can start with C major or a closely related chord to C major and use the omnibus progression to modulate to E major. I know that some keys are reachable by an omnibus progression from a certain chord and others aren't(at least if you are taking about using the dominant or leading tone chord of the new key to confirm a modulation to the new key).

But can E major be reached by an omnibus progression from C major or a chord closely related to C major? Or is the major mediant, which has a chromatic mediant relationship to C major unreachable by this method?

  • thank you for the term omnibus progression. Never heard about it before, learnt something new! en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_progression (btw. did you also try a direct modulation from C to E? ) – Albrecht Hügli Dec 22 '19 at 10:28
  • I haven't tried a direct modulation between those 2 keys. Just from the term direct modulation it sounds like an abrupt change, which I might not necessarily want(I do often aim for smooth modulations between keys). However, when I listen to the "Pastoral Symphony" in F major, that Bb to D motion feels smooth, almost as though it was meant to be, and it is a direct modulation to a chromatic mediant. I think part of the reason why that particular direct modulation feels smooth has to do with the arpeggios that Beethoven uses in the Bb to D modulation in his "Pastoral Symphony". – Caters Dec 22 '19 at 16:17
  • I recognize now what you mean by omnibus progression: It is one of the first progressions I developed in a Cornet Duet with piano accompaniment 1963, but at that time the term onmibus was not in use. – Albrecht Hügli Dec 27 '19 at 13:32
0

Now, I know that the second to last chord, I want to be either a B7 or a D#°7, since both of those are dominant function chords that will smoothly resolve to E major.

I agree with you that the omnibus progression has to be in B7.

But can E major be reached by an omnibus progression from C major or a chord closely related to C major?

I don't know a trick to get there from C. But I've found a chord related to C would fit fine to B7: C -> Ab.

I tried this in a 3/4 time and it sounds quite fine:

The last chord of the C section could end right in Ab (false cadence V -> bVI) or it ends on C (V7-I), followed by one measure in Ab, then the bass starts e.g. in a 3/4 (half note, quarter note ... etc.) from the 5th of Ab: Eb=D#_D,C#_C,B7__,B7__ (the B7 last 2 bars), the middle voices stay on the 5th and 7th (F#,A) and the upper part leads chromatically from B to D#

and the new section in E can begin.

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.